Skip to content

Customer Service Rep

Own every customer outcome: Gorgias to zero daily, orders protected, reviews managed, and every reply in the warm Hardcore voice.

11 tasks · 12 videos · 19-question quiz · pass at 90%

Tickets & Our Voice

2

Clear the inbox daily — Gorgias hits zero every day, no exceptions. Move fast, communicate clearly, and own the entire customer outcome from open to resolved.

1Handling Tickets in GorgiasUnassigned first, then My Tickets, then Open. Two macros per response. Zero by end of shift.
  • Work the views in order: Unassigned (knock out easy/macro tickets first) → My Tickets (ongoing conversations) → Open Tickets (help if appropriate).
  • Use TWO macros per response: one to respond, one to sign off. If a macro fires a Shopify action, double-check it before executing. Correct any misspelled names macros pull in.
  • Replacements = duplicate the order, 100% discount, and leave an internal note.
  • Phone calls: no voicemail → assign to Phone Support. With voicemail → listen, leave an internal note, merge customer info, handle by email if possible.
  • No macro fits? Email: start nice → solve the issue → end nice. Social: casual, quick replies are fine.
  • Check the Spam view, review closed tickets to learn, offer coupons when needed, and run the cycle 2–3 times per shift.

▶ Watch: Customer Service Daily Check

▶ Watch: How to Reply to Customers Without a Macro

How to Use Gorgias (Guide)Open guide ↗
2The Hardcore Response FormatEvery reply is a sandwich: warm open, solve the problem, warm close.

The six steps, in order

  • Greet: "Ciao" + the customer's name.
  • Thank them sincerely — there is always a genuine reason, no matter how frustrated they are ("Thank you for your order!", "Thank you for bringing this to our attention!").
  • Confirm you understand the problem ("I understand you're having problems with X").
  • Solve it — give the real answer and fix it in Shopify.
  • Offer future help — you're available for any questions.
  • Sign off warm, seasonal when it fits ("Wear It Proud," "Buon Natale,") with your name.

Space the steps apart, sandwich every response (nice → solve → nice), and represent Hardcore the way we want to be represented. AI bot responses get reviewed and improved against this same standard.

▶ Watch: Review & Improve AI Bot Responses

Orders, Delays & Backorders

4

Customers must never be left waiting without proactive communication. Check ShipHero before promising anything — and never give exact restock dates unless confirmed.

1Daily Shopify & Marketplace ChecksEvery filter, every day: Open, Shirt Club, Amazon, TikTok, Chargebacks, O&F.
  • Review every Shopify filter daily: Open (flag anything >48 hours), Shirt Club Welcome and Recurring (checked manually — they don't show in Open), Amazon (72-hour ship SLA — account risk), TikTok (late = penalties), Chargebacks (new ones same day), O&F (archive orders that didn't auto-fulfill).
  • Marketplace audit: log into TikTok, Amazon, and Walmart seller portals each morning; anything Unshipped 24+ hours gets investigated — backorder? active PO? system error?
  • In-stock but unshipped → email Zipscale: "PRIORITY SHIPMENT REQUEST: [Marketplace] - Order #". Out of stock → contact the customer with an alternative or refund (or cancel if the marketplace forbids OOS messaging — protect account health).
  • TikTok tracking sync fails after 4–8 hours → add tracking manually in Seller Center (approved carriers only: USPS via TikTok 4PL, UPS, FedEx, DHL, OnTrac). Escalate unapproved carriers to Zipscale; open a TikTok support ticket if manual entry fails.

▶ Watch: Review Unfulfilled Orders > 48 Hours

▶ Watch: ShipHero Runthrough

2Outreach for Waiting Customers7+ days unfulfilled → check the PO, reach out, and escalate contact attempts until resolved.
  • At 7 days unfulfilled: confirm the cause and check ShipHero → Purchase Orders for an active PO.
  • On a PO: proactive update — item is incoming, no exact dates unless confirmed, you'll notify when it ships. Follow up weekly, and within 24 hours of any PO change. ETA past 3 weeks → strongly recommend alternatives.
  • Not on a PO: high priority — offer alternatives immediately. The safe general line: "most products are restocked within 30 business days of sellout" plus a Back in Stock signup, never a specific date.
  • The outreach ladder: Email → 48 hours → second email → 48 hours → phone call (voicemail + summary email if no answer). Document every attempt in Shopify and Gorgias.

Offering alternatives

  • Always at least three options: swap variant (size/color/similar item), switch product (discount code covers a higher price, refund the difference on lower), store credit (gift card), refund (always available, least-promoted).
  • Process swaps as a new order at 100% discount with notes. Document the delay reason, options offered, choice, and actions.

▶ Watch: Add Customers to Back in Stock Notifications

3Dropshipping Long-Wait ItemsWhen bulk ordering doesn't make sense, fulfill via Printful — without ever saying "dropship" to the customer.
  • When: only a handful of backorders for a SKU, no reorder planned, or the incoming PO won't cover this order — and the customer would otherwise wait more than a week.
  • Recreate the order exactly in Printful (product, color, size, print file, customer address), best shipping speed.
  • Mark fulfilled in Shopify when Printful confirms, add tracking, and note why it was dropshipped.
  • Tell the customer their order is "being fulfilled through our production partner" — never say dropshipping.
  • The gift-card alternative: when there is no plan to restock and the customer would rather not wait, cancel the order and issue a gift card for $5–$10 more than they paid — customers often take it and order something else. When canceling, be careful not to click the refund option (store credit replaces it); if the customer wants a refund instead, give the full refund.
  • Gift cards: Shopify → Products → Gift cards → Create. Set the expiration 3 years from today, search the customer, and always note why it was issued.
  • Either way, alert the warehouse team in Slack to check inventory on the item so the same hold doesn't happen again.

▶ Watch: Resolving Held Orders: Gift Card or Printful Dropship

▶ Watch: How to Issue a Gift Card

How to Drop-Ship a One-Off Shirt on Printful (Guide)Open guide ↗
4ChargebacksReach the customer first; if that fails, submit a complete response before the deadline.
  • Orders → filter Chargeback = Open. Call and email the customer first — many resolve directly, and a written reply from the customer confirming delivery is the best evidence there is.
  • No response → Submit Response: upload the shipping label (Reprint Label → download PDF), link hardcoreitalians.com/pages/terms, and add screenshots of the terms and the delivery confirmation.
  • Write the response professionally in the standard format: address the bank, thank them for a proper investigation, lay out the sequence (ordered on X, shipped X, delivered X, alerted at every step), and quote the terms that apply — accurate address is the customer's responsibility, and we are not responsible for lost or stolen packages.
  • The bank wants a reason to keep the money — thorough, professional, evidence-heavy responses win cases. Watch the dispute deadline (typically ~30 days) and submit before it expires either way.

▶ Watch: How To Submit Chargebacks

Reviews, Subscriptions & Deliverability

4
1Managing Yotpo ReviewsDaily: answer questions, respond to negatives same-day, approve pictures manually.
  • The daily order of operations: answer new questions first, then the scheduled-to-publish queue, then the total-reviews check.
  • Questions: public reply if other shoppers benefit ("all our tees are 100% cotton"); private reply if it's customer-specific or negative — about 90% of the time private is right. When unsure whether something should be public on the website, ask before posting.
  • Positive product reviews that fit the site → save as both Product AND Website review.
  • The scheduled-to-publish queue is Yotpo's AI holding back reviews it suspects you don't want live. If nobody acts within 30 days they auto-publish to the website — that is why this queue must hit zero daily. Reject 1–3 star reviews and handle the customer privately like any CS ticket; a mild low-star review can be let through occasionally (roughly one a month) so the reviews look real. Catch the traps: a 5-star review with a negative comment gets rejected too, and so does anything with profanity.
  • Total reviews: read every review that comes in — the AI misses negatives ("looks cheaper in person" once made it to the site). Reject those and reach out to the customer to make it right.
  • Pictures: Yotpo never auto-approves photos. Filter Total Reviews by media and approve the good ones — social proof sells. Careful: the media filter breaks date sorting, so checking daily beats digging through a random-order backlog.

▶ Watch: Check, Monitor, and Respond to Reviews

2Recharge Subscription PaymentsRescue failed payments before the 5-attempt cutoff, clean out abandoned subscriptions, and send the final outreach.
  • Recharge → Order Errors → All Active Errors, checked daily or every other day. The system retries a maximum of 5 times before auto-canceling.
  • Temporary declines or unexpected errors → manual Retry. Invalid payment method → reach out via Gorgias to update billing first.
  • Failed payment + last successful order 6+ months ago → cancel the subscription (reason: abandoned account). Check Gorgias for recent contact first.
  • At exactly 5 attempts → create a Gorgias ticket and send the approved outreach email ("Action Required: Update your payment method...") with the account portal link. Tag it Payment Failure.
3Email Deliverability IssuesWhen customers say our emails never arrive: test, diagnose, escalate — and reach them directly meanwhile.
  • Test outbound and inbound on the contact@ address (check Spam/Promotions folders on the receiving end).
  • Run Mail-Tester or MXToolbox for blacklist flags and SPF/DKIM errors.
  • Failures → ticket with Gorgias Support including the ticket ID and test results.
  • Urgent customer needs meanwhile: email them directly from your @hardcoreitalians.com address, explain why, and link it back to the Gorgias ticket.
4Amazon Listings & Seller SupportFix ghost listings and SKU mismatches through Marketplace Connect; know the path to a human at Amazon.
  • Shopify → Apps → Marketplace Connect → Amazon tab. Unlist ghost listings, use Link Listings → Match to fix SKU mismatches, fix titles/descriptions in Attribute Mapping. Verify in Seller Central afterward.
  • Seller Support: Help → Get Support → Selling on Amazon. Don't type your issue into the search — click "Browse for your issue in the menu" to reach real categories. Lead with the ASIN/Order ID and a clear action request.
  • Phone/chat for urgent, email for documentation. Always record the Case ID in internal notes.

Faire Wholesale

1

Wholesale buyers are businesses — the same warm Hardcore voice, with tighter promises. This workflow is shared with the Operations Coordinator.

1Faire Wholesale OrdersAccept within 24 hours, categorize the inventory type, send the matching macro, and log the retailer for a social feature.

Faire is our wholesale channel — Italian delis, restaurants, and shops stocking Hardcore Italians merch. The workflow covers prompt acceptance, personalized retailer onboarding with a social media collaboration invite, and shipping communication matched to the inventory type.

The workflow

  • Log into the Faire portal daily at the start of each shift. Accept incoming orders within 24 hours of placement.
  • Categorize the order's SKUs: Ready-to-Ship (in-stock warehouse inventory), Mixed (stock + custom printed-on-demand), or Printed-on-Demand only.
  • Send the matching onboarding macro via Faire direct messaging the moment you accept.
  • Log the retailer's details and any photos they send in the Faire Social Media Outreach Tracker for feature scheduling.
  • Dispatch: Ready-to-Ship processes for fulfillment; Mixed dispatches the in-stock items immediately with POD following separately; POD-only goes straight to the production partners.

The three macros and their promises

  • Macro 1 — Ready-to-Ship only: order ships within 5 days (depending on bulk), tracking to follow.
  • Macro 2 — Mixed order: in-stock items dispatch immediately; the printed-on-demand portion ships separately and arrives within 12 days of order acceptance.
  • Macro 3 — POD only: items are custom-made in production and arrive within 12 days of order acceptance.

Every macro opens "Ciao [Retailer Name]", thanks them for bringing us into their shop, and invites them to be featured on our Instagram stories and reels — asking for a photo or two of their in-store Hardcore Italians displays plus a brief note on their business story (founders, Italian roots, what makes the shop unique). The full copy-paste macro text lives in the Faire SOP in the SOP library.

Checks for success

Before anything ships, run through this list.

  • Is Gorgias at zero before signing off?
  • Were all Shopify filters checked — including Shirt Club, Amazon, TikTok, and Chargebacks?
  • Did every reply follow the sandwich format with two macros?
  • Were negative reviews answered the same day?
  • Does every delayed order have documented outreach in Shopify and Gorgias?
  • Did you avoid promising any unconfirmed restock date?
  • Are Amazon/TikTok orders confirmed safe from late penalties?
  • Was the EOD report submitted on Slack?

Ready to check your understanding?

19 questions on everything above. You need 90% to pass — screenshot your result and send it to your manager.

Take the quiz